A Brief Introduction to Auteur Theory
Film 101: What
Is an Auteur? Learn About Auteur Theory
Last updated: Oct 2, 2020
https://www.masterclass.com/articles/film-101-what-is-an-auteur#what-is-an-auteur
What Is an Auteur?
The concept of the auteur—of the filmmaker as artist and
author of his or her works—began in Paris, where filmmakers and critics reacted
to the industrialization of filmmaking in the United States and Europe.
What Is Auteur Theory?
Director François Truffaut, writing as a critic in the
influential French journal Cahiers du Cinéma (Cinema Notebook), developed the
concept of the auteur in his 1954 essay “Une certaine tendance du cinéma
français” (“A certain trend in French cinema”).
Truffaut wrote about the films of several new French
filmmakers who he termed auteurs. He drew contrasts between auteurs and
directors of mainstream studio movies—who he dismissed as merely metteur en
scene, or “stagers” of a script written by another artist. Truffaut argued that
the filmmakers who made the best films were those who wrote and directed their
own films and who had a unique, personal vision. Truffaut called that approach
La politique des auteurs (“The policy of the authors”). Truffaut’s ideas on film
were embraced by an era of French filmmakers who were part of what he called La
Nouvelle Vague (what English speakers call the French New Wave).
What Is the Difference Between Auteur Directors and
Other Film Directors?
Auteurs wrote and directed films that went beyond surface
level stories to ask bigger questions about human existence and explore deeper
themes in a nuanced and skillful way. Whereas most directors translated scripts
written by others to the screen, auteurs usually write their own screenplays or
at the very least have a heavy editorial hand in the writing process.
The 3 Components of Auteur Theory
Andrew Sarris, film critic for The New York Times, expanded on
Truffaut’s writing and set out a more comprehensive definition for auteurs
according to three main criteria: technical competence, distinguishable
personality, and interior meaning.
1.
Technical competence: Auteurs must
be at the top of their craft in terms of technical filmmaking abilities. Auteurs
always have a hand in multiple components of filmmaking and should be operating
at a high level across the board.
2.
Distinguishable personality: What
separates auteurs from other technically gifted directors is their unmistakable
personality and style. When looking at an auteur’s collected works, you can
generally see shared filming techniques and consistent themes being explored.
One of the primary tenets of auteur theory is that auteurs make movies that are
unmistakably theirs. This is in sharp contrast with the standard studio
directors of the era who were simply translating script to screen with little
interrogation of the source material or editorial input.
3.
Interior meaning: Auteurs make
films that have layers of meaning and have more to say about the human
condition. Films made by auteurs go beyond the pure entertainment-oriented
spectacles produced by large studios, to instead reveal the filmmakers unique
perspectives and ruminations on life.
Film Terms – Repetition, Quotation, Borrowing
Repetition –
Directors repeat themselves between films they direct. They often repeat themes,
topics, and styles.
Quotation –
Directors quote themselves. Their films repeat character types, characters’
names, film setting, and/or visual motifs. Quotation is a type of repetition;
they are more direct use of repetition and are more concrete things in the films
like names, places, or types of people. The director may do this on purpose or
on accident, but directors quote themselves because they like what they did
previously and not because they lack imagination.
Borrowing - Directors borrow from other directors. One director ‘borrows’ a quote or an idea from the film of a different director. This borrowing is a way to show respect towards the original directors whose work is being quoted. Directors borrow from other great directors to give homage to the legacy of that great director and not because the director doing the quoting does not have new ideas.